Purchasing a new Tesla represents more than just buying a car – it’s an investment in cutting-edge technology, sustainability, and a premium driving experience. The excitement of driving home in your new electric vehicle comes with expectations of reliability and performance that match the premium price tag. But what happens when your Tesla experience is marred by persistent issues, repeated repair attempts, and growing frustration? At American Lemon Law Group, we understand both the financial and emotional impact of dealing with a defective Tesla.
You shouldn’t have to struggle with recurring problems in a vehicle that represents such a significant investment. Our experienced Los Angeles lemon law lawyers specialize in holding Tesla accountable under California’s strong consumer protection laws. If you’re experiencing ongoing issues with your Tesla, call us today at (877) 311-1133 or reach out online for a free consultation about your legal options.
99% Success Rate35+ Years Experience1,000+ Cases Won
Work With Us
Don’t let a bad car drain your time and money — let us help you get what you’re owed.
How Can Tesla Lemon Law Help Me?
California’s Lemon Law provides powerful protections for Tesla owners experiencing persistent defects. When your electric vehicle fails to meet reasonable quality and reliability standards despite multiple repair attempts, the law can compel Tesla to provide a replacement or refund.
Tesla vehicles, despite their technological advancements, have experienced documented defects that may qualify under lemon law provisions.
According to official manufacturer communications and NHTSA investigations and recalls, Tesla has faced significant challenges with several critical systems:
- Steering system defects, including the recent NHTA Recall 25V092 affecting 376,241 Model 3/Y vehicles (2023 models) with firmware flaws in the electronic power-assisted steering system
- Software issues, like the Full Self-Driving Beta “Rolling Stop” Violation (Recall SB2500004) that required over-the-air updates
- Battery and charging system problems affecting range and performance
- Autopilot malfunctions and unexpected behavior
- Persistent touchscreen failures affecting essential vehicle functions
If your Tesla has been in the shop repeatedly for the same issue, or if multiple problems have kept your vehicle out of service for an extended period, you may be entitled to significant compensation. The California Lemon Law can provide:
- A complete buyback of your defective Tesla
- A replacement vehicle of equal value
- Cash compensation while keeping your vehicle
- Reimbursement for expenses related to the defect
- Payment of your attorney fees by Tesla
Is Your Tesla a Lemon?
Under California law, your Tesla may qualify as a “lemon” if it has substantial defects that impair its use, value, or safety, and these issues persist despite a reasonable number of repair attempts during the warranty period. While each case is unique, there are general guidelines that can help determine if your Tesla meets the legal definition of a lemon:
Your Tesla May Qualify if:
- The defect substantially impairs the vehicle’s use, value, or safety
- The problems began while under the manufacturer’s warranty
- Tesla has made two or more attempts to repair a serious safety defect
- Tesla has made four or more attempts to repair the same non-safety defect
- Your Tesla has been out of service for repairs for a total of 30 days or more (not necessarily consecutive)
- The problems are not the result of abuse or unauthorized modifications
Warranties Applicable to Tesla Vehicles:
Understanding your warranty coverage is crucial for lemon law claims:
- New Vehicle Limited Warranty: 4 years or 50,000 miles, whichever comes first
- CPO Tesla Warranty: Remainder of original warranty plus potential additional coverage
It’s important to note that recent changes to California’s Lemon Law have affected used vehicle coverage. Following the California Supreme Court ruling in Rodriguez v. FCA, used vehicles with an unexpired manufacturer’s warranty are no longer eligible for lemon law remedies unless they were sold as Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicles with a new car warranty issued at the time of sale. This change took effect in 2024 and significantly impacts Tesla buyers.
How does Tesla Lemon Law Buyback Work?
When your Tesla qualifies as a lemon, you have several options for compensation. The process typically begins with a formal demand to Tesla, detailing the defects, repair history, and requested remedy:
The Buyback Process:
- Documentation: Gather all service records, repair orders, and communications with Tesla
- Legal Consultation: Have an experienced attorney evaluate your case
- Pre-suit Notice: Under the new Assembly Bill 1755 (effective April 1, 2025), consumers must provide written notice to Tesla at least 30 days before filing a lawsuit
- Demand Letter: Your attorney sends a formal demand outlining your claim and requested remedy
- Negotiation: Tesla reviews the claim and may make a settlement offer
- Resolution: Accept a fair settlement or proceed to litigation if necessary
If Tesla agrees to a buyback, they are required to refund:
- The full purchase price or payoff amount of your loan/lease
- Registration fees, financing charges, and other official fees
- Transportation expenses and rental car costs related to the defect
- Less a mileage offset for the use you received before problems began
With the implementation of AB 1755, the lemon law process now includes expedited procedures, including early discovery, expedited depositions, and mandatory mediation for manufacturers who opt-in. These changes aim to streamline the resolution process, potentially leading to faster outcomes for Tesla owners.
Will Tesla Buyback My Car?
Tesla, like other manufacturers, may initially resist lemon law claims. However, with proper documentation and legal representation, many Tesla owners have successfully obtained buybacks or replacements. The key to a successful claim lies in establishing that your vehicle meets the legal criteria and that Tesla had reasonable opportunities to fix the problems.
Essential Evidence for Your Tesla Lemon Law Claim:
- Service Records: All repair orders showing dates, problems reported, and work performed
- Communications: Emails, texts, and other correspondence with Tesla service centers
- Diagnostic Reports: Technical findings from Tesla’s service system
- Timeline: Detailed account of when problems occurred and repairs were attempted
- Witness Statements: Statements from passengers who experienced the defects
- Expert Opinions: Technical evaluations of the persistent defects
It’s worth noting that Tesla’s software-dominated recall strategy, which often relies on over-the-air updates, creates unique documentation challenges for lemon law claims. For example, the February 2025 recall (NHTA 25V092) addressing steering system firmware flaws was remedied through remote updates (version 2023.38.4), but the underlying issue may persist in some vehicles despite the update.
Under the updated statute of limitations in AB 1755, you now have one year after the final warranty expires to file suit, or six years total after the delivery of your Tesla. This extended timeframe provides more opportunity to document persistent issues, but also makes timely legal consultation even more important.
No Cost to You$50M+ Recovered for ClientsFast Results
Stuck with a lemon?
We help Californians get paid.
Contact a Tesla Lemon Law Attorney Today
If you’re experiencing persistent issues with your Tesla despite multiple repair attempts, don’t continue to struggle with a defective vehicle. The recent changes to California’s Lemon Law make it more important than ever to work with attorneys who understand the latest legal developments and Tesla’s specific defect patterns.
At American Lemon Law Group, we have successfully represented numerous Tesla owners in obtaining fair compensation for defective vehicles. Our attorneys understand both the technical complexities of Tesla’s systems and the emotional toll of dealing with a problematic vehicle.
We offer:
- Free, no-obligation case evaluations
- Contingency fee representation (no fees unless we win)
- Comprehensive case management from start to finish (no referrals)
- Deep expertise in Tesla-specific defects and repair patterns
- Up-to-date knowledge of the latest lemon law amendments
Don’t let Tesla’s reputation for innovation prevent you from seeking the compensation you deserve for a defective vehicle.
In addition to Tesla vehicles, we also handle cases involving the following automobile manufacturers:
Call us today at (877) 311-1133 for a free consultation, or fill out our online form for a prompt response from our team of experienced Tesla lemon law attorneys.